Our ReviewMuscleMedsCarnivor
MuscleMeds Carnivor stands out with its unique approach to muscle nutrition. This protein powder deviates from the norm by featuring hydrolyzed beef protein isolate as its primary protein source, a choice that's particularly intriguing for those exploring alternatives to traditional whey or plant-based proteins. Each serving, sized at a substantial 36.4g scoop, packs 23g of protein while maintaining a lean profile with zero fat and low net carbs – just 5g. What sets Carnivor apart is not just its beef-derived protein but also the added blend of creatine monohydrate and BCAAs, designed to enhance muscle growth and recovery. This product seems tailor-made for those looking to bulk up or maintain lean muscle mass, offering a high-protein solution that aligns with various dietary needs, including those avoiding lactose or looking for low-fat options. The inclusion of anabolic nitrogen retention technology furthers its appeal, aiming to optimize protein utilization and muscle repair.
Ingredients
MuscleMeds Carnivor's ingredients list is quite a standout in the protein powder landscape. The key component here, hydrolyzed beef protein isolate, is an innovative choice. This form of protein is known for its high digestibility and rapid absorption, making it a great post-workout option for muscle recovery. Plus, for those with lactose intolerance or dairy sensitivities, this beef-based protein offers a commendable alternative to the more common whey or plant-based options.
Another notable inclusion is the creatine monohydrate. Creatine is widely recognized for its role in improving strength, increasing lean muscle mass, and helping muscles recover more quickly during exercise. This makes it a valuable addition, particularly for those focused on strength training.
The presence of BCAAs (l-leucine, l-valine, l-isoleucine) in the formula is also a big plus. These essential amino acids are crucial for muscle protein synthesis and recovery, making them an important component in any athlete's nutrition regime.
Then, there's the Anabolic Nitrogen Retention Technology™ intermediates (GKG, OKG, AKG, and KIC). These are designed to enhance the utilization of the high levels of amino acids in beef protein and could be beneficial in optimizing muscle growth and recovery.
However, the product does contain some ingredients that might raise eyebrows. Maltodextrin, a common carbohydrate additive, could be a concern for those watching their carb intake closely, though does provide some immediate energy. Similarly, the inclusion of artificial sweeteners like acesulfame potassium and sucralose might not sit well with everyone, especially those who prefer natural ingredients or have sensitivities to artificial sweeteners.
MuscleMeds Carnivor's ingredient profile is a mix of innovative and effective components, especially the hydrolyzed beef protein isolate and added BCAAs and creatine. It's a solid choice for those looking for a non-dairy protein source with added muscle-building benefits, but it might not tick all the boxes for those seeking a more natural ingredient list.
Effectiveness
MuscleMeds Carnivor’s standout feature is undoubtedly its protein source – hydrolyzed beef protein isolate. This particular type of protein is known for its rapid absorption rate, which is crucial for post-workout recovery when muscles are in dire need of protein to start the repair process. With 23 grams of protein per 36.4g scoop, Carnivor efficiently meets the high protein requirements necessary for muscle repair and growth.
The addition of creatine monohydrate and branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) significantly bolsters this protein powder's muscle-building capabilities. Creatine is a well-researched supplement known for enhancing strength, power, and muscle mass, making it a great companion to protein for those engaged in strength and resistance training. BCAAs, comprising l-leucine, l-valine, and l-isoleucine, are crucial for muscle protein synthesis. Their presence in the mix means that Carnivor not only aids in muscle recovery but also helps in minimizing muscle breakdown during workouts.
Another positive aspect is the lower net carb and non-existent fat content per serving. This makes Carnivor an excellent choice for those aiming to build lean muscle mass without the addition of excess calories from fats and carbohydrates. The low-calorie count per serving (120 calories) also aligns well with various diet plans, especially for those who are calorie-conscious.
However, there are a couple of factors that slightly limit the product's overall effectiveness score. While hydrolyzed beef protein isolate is a high-quality protein source and a novel option for those avoiding dairy, its digestion speed, while fast, may not be as rapid as whey protein isolate. This could potentially make a minor difference in the immediate post-workout window.
Taste
The taste of chocolate was not too bad but very sweet, perhaps a bit too sweet for us. We could detect a bit of a meaty flavor too, however, the chocolate probably masked it a fair bit. I’m not sure the vanilla flavor would do quite so well as masking its natural beef isolate flavor.
The texture of Carnivor is noteworthy. On mixing with water, the powder dissolves fairly well, but it does tend to create a slightly thicker shake than with other proteins. This could be a plus for those who prefer a more substantial feel to their shakes. However, for those who favor a lighter, more fluid consistency, this might be a slight drawback. When mixed with milk, the shake becomes creamier and richer, which some might find enhances the overall flavor profile.
Mixability is an area where Carnivor does quite well, albeit with a caveat. It mixes smoothly with minimal clumping. But, there's noticeable foaming, which seems to be more pronounced than in many whey proteins. While this doesn't affect the flavor or the nutritional value, it does alter the drinking experience slightly.
Compared to other protein powders, especially those based on whey or plant proteins, Carnivor's taste and texture are distinctive. The beef protein base imparts a different flavor and mouthfeel, which, while not unpleasant, is definitely different from the norm.
Value
Evaluating the value of MuscleMeds Carnivor, especially in the context of its unique ingredient profile and overall performance, places it in an interesting position in the spectrum of protein powders. It's not quite a budget option, nor does it hit the high price point of some premium products. Instead, Carnivor sits comfortably in the mid-range category, offering a balance between cost and quality that is worth considering.
The defining feature of Carnivor is its use of hydrolyzed beef protein isolate, a less common protein source in the market dominated by whey and plant-based options. This choice of protein not only differentiates it in terms of taste and nutritional profile but also in terms of cost. Beef protein isolate is a high-quality protein source, and the process of hydrolyzing it for better absorption and digestibility likely contributes to the product's pricing. When compared to standard whey protein powders, Carnivor may seem a tad more expensive, but this is justified by its unique offering and the added benefits of creatine and BCAAs. These additions enhance the product's value, especially for those seeking more than just a basic protein supplement.
Another aspect to consider is the product's suitability for a broader range of dietary needs, including those who are lactose intolerant or seeking non-dairy protein sources. This widens its appeal and can justify the price for a segment of consumers who might have limited options.
In comparison to other mid-range and premium protein powders, Carnivor holds its own, particularly in its effectiveness and unique ingredient profile. The cost per serving is very reasonable when considering the high protein content, the inclusion of creatine and BCAAs, and the benefits of a beef-based protein.
Conclusion
MuscleMeds Carnivor stands out particularly due to its unique source of protein – hydrolyzed beef protein isolate. This choice not only caters to those with lactose intolerance but also offers a high-quality protein alternative to the more common whey and plant-based options. The addition of creatine and BCAAs enhances its appeal, making it an effective choice for muscle growth and recovery. Its lower mid-range pricing positions it well against competitors, offering a good balance between cost and quality. While the taste may require an adjustment period and the presence of artificial additives might not appeal to all, its overall effectiveness and unique offering make it a worthy consideration. This product is especially recommendable for those seeking a non-dairy protein source with additional muscle-building benefits.
Where to buy?
The protein matrix includes the primary protein components included in this product. These protein sources are listed in order of volume from greatest to least in the product.
This diagram provides the digestion profile for the protein types contained within this product. The chart plots the digestion of the included protein types over an hourly timeframe. All profiles have their advantages depending on your goals. More information regarding digestion and timing can be found in our guides.
The cost indicators provide a relative cost comparison with all protein products. The lower the score the better!
The "Product Cost Indicator" provides the comparative product cost, as a whole.
The "Protein Cost Indicator" provides a comparative cost based on only the protein component. While this can be useful for comparing products excluding fillers, many additional ingredients can provide additional benefits and value.
Note: Products that serve a dual purpose, such as mass gainers and ketogenic powders don't include the "Protein Cost Indicator".
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.